Ministers that served the church

1741 – 1754    Cyrus Marsh
1756 – 1811    Joel Bordwell
1813 – 1823    Asa Blair
1823 – 1829    Laurens P. Hickok
1834 – 1849    William W. Andrews
1853 – 1854    William W. Page
1856 – 1859    Elisha Whittlesey
1859 – 1867    Evarts Scudder
1867 – 1870    Edward P. Payson
1871 – 1873    Arthur Crosby
1874 – 1879    Thomas D. Barclay
1879 – 1883    J.H. Vorce
1883 – 1889    Elbert S. Porter
1889 – 1896    Benjamin M. Wright
1896 – 1897    Howard Mudie
1897 – 1898    J. Spencer Vorhees
1898 – 1908    Herbert K. Job
1909 – 1919    Clarence H. Perry
1919 – 1921    Henry Blake
1921 – 1923    Thomas S. Cleaver
1923 – 1925    Lee A. Hanchett
1926 – 1939    Henry M. Bartlett
1939 – 1942    Leon A. Dickinson, Jr.
1943 – 1948    Elmer J. Hostetler
1948 – 1949    William Whiston
1949 – 1952    Randolph H. Hill
1952 – 1956    William Hindle
1956 – 1962    David J. Heintzelman
1963 – 1966    Richard J. Nordgren
1967 – 1972    Donald Ketcham
1972 – 1973    Charles T. Russ
1973 – 1978    H. Macy Whitehead
1979 – 1979    Harry W. Tribble
1980 – 1986    Robert W. Hoskins
1986 – 1987    Mary N. Hawkes
1987 – 1995    Glen E. Rainsley
1993 – 2017    Melinda Miko Keck
2017 – 2019     Abby Gackenheimer
2019 –              John David Heeckt